Mapserver Enterprise vs Mapserver Cheetah

Note: I have rewritten this article after crtitics which was deserved a bit:-)

To whom it may concern.. This is still a bit naming mess. The two pieces of software have almost nothing to to do with each other.
“Mapserver Enterprise” simply does’n exist anymore and is now called MapGuide Open Source, open source approach to web mapping, based on original Autodesk’s code. Despite of the former name, there is no “child” version of UMN Mapserver nor fork, there’s one Mapserver. A bit of history – Autodesk entered in free GIS in 2005 with its MapGuide. As they were publishing a huge amount of code I think that they wanted to make it a big way. They invented these two names, but there was little response for calling Mapserver other names.. Now, the name “Mapserver Enterprise” is not promoted anymore and the product resides on http://mapguide.osgeo.org/. Anyway, some people from Autodesk still call it so – I have heard it recently on GlobalGeo in Barcelona. But it is probably only a mistake – Mapserver Enterprise simply doesn’t exist anymore.

MapGuide is not written in Java  as I originally thougt, but “entirely coded in cross-platform C++, using SWIG to generate the user-facing web APIs” (citing Jason Birch) and has some quite interesting features – i.e. using DXF vector plugin in browser, extensive ajax use etc. This comparing to old unix-like C/C++ mapserver may appear really to be anvaced edition. I certainly think that != true; Everybody can choose the best for his needs – oh wait there is already Geoserver! Cool J2EE app built with GeoTools.

Advertisements

3 Responses to “Mapserver Enterprise vs Mapserver Cheetah”

  1. Random Nodes » Who writes history?: Jason Birch's geospatial ramblings Says:

    […] the MapServer community. I thought that this had all been worked out, but Karel Cech just posted a semi-informed rant on the subject and brought it up […]

  2. Robert Bray Says:

    For the record, Autodesk did not invent the name MapServer Cheetah. That name came from and was promoted by a member of the MapServer community. Autodesk also quickly responded to the communities concern over the naming MapServer Enterprise, changing the name within a very short period of time to MapGuide Open Source.

    Now as for terminology MapServer is a very generic term. What is MapServer? A map server. What is MapGuide? A map server. What is GeoServer? A map server.

    At their core all of these things are map servers. They each have their strengths and weaknesses, and to some degree a different focus. However you can see how it is easy to call any of these projects a map server. That said Autodesk does not promote or condone the use of the name MapServer Enterprise.

  3. Seven of Nine : Resistence is Futile Says:

    OSGeo Celebrates Fifth Anniversay…

    Do you remember where you were on Feb Four 2006? Yes, I remember well because I was part of the group that met in Chicago to found OSGeo. I was honored to end up as one of the Interim Board of Directors. I also vividly remember how Markus Neteler and m…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: